NYC Marathon goal 3 wk after Chicago Marathon
Hi Coach Katelyn,
I’m 54 and started running about 13 years ago. My first marathon was over 4:30 9 years ago and I ran my first Sub 3 marathon last year. This spring, I ran my 10th marathon at Boston but missed my goal (sub 255) by 20 seconds. I trained quite hard during the summer for Chicago and this time the weather didn’t help. With about 4 minute positive splits, I finished a little over 2:58. My question is, if weather is perfect at below 45F, do you think it is realistic to try sub 255 again at NYC, which is only 3 weeks after Chicago. My original plan was to run hard in Chicago and run easy in NYC. But now I’m more impatient now lol.

Hi!
First of all, congratulations on some incredible progress over the years! Going from a 4:30+ marathon to sub-3 is a huge accomplishment, and coming within 20 seconds of 2:55 at Boston is seriously impressive!
I completely understand the temptation to go after that goal again, especially when you know you're capable of it and the weather didn't cooperate in Chicago. But I'm going to give you my conservative coaching perspective here: I really wouldn't recommend turning NYC into what we call a revenge race.
You gave Chicago your all, and your body needs at least three weeks just to recover from that marathon effort, if not longer. Even if you're feeling good on the outside, there's still a lot of muscular damage and accumulated fatigue that takes time to resolve.
Plus, NYC is a challenging, hilly course! Even with perfect weather, it's not exactly the ideal place to chase a PR, especially just three weeks after another all-out marathon.
My concern is that pushing for sub-2:55 so soon could increase your risk of injury or leave you even more discouraged if things don't go according to plan. And I would hate for that to happen after all the hard work you've put in!
My advice would be to stick with your original plan for NYC, keep it easy, enjoy the experience, and save that sub-2:55 attempt for another marathon further down the road. Give yourself time to properly recover, rebuild, and line up feeling fresh and ready to race.
I know that's probably not the exciting answer you were hoping for, haha! But you've already proven you're right there. You don't need to rush another attempt to prove anything. That sub-2:55 is absolutely worth chasing, just not at the expense of your health or long-term progress!
Haha! That's exactly what I expected you to advise, but I didn't want you to. Thanks for your advice!!