Perhaps one of the most counterintuitive things about the sport of running is that you oftentimes need to run slower to actually run faster. Many runners end up in the “gray zone,” described as Zone 3 training, which can ultimately inhibit potential improvements.
What is Zone 3 training? Is there a “grey zone“ in running? Can you run junk miles, or are all runs beneficial to your health, fitness, and performance?
In this article, we will discuss Zone 3 running, if there is a grey zone in running, and whether Zone 3 training is junk miles or valuable work.
We will cover:
- What Is Zone 3 Training?
- What Are the Benefits of Zone 3 Training?
- Why Is Zone 3 Training Considered the Grey Zone of Running?
- Should You Train In Zone 3?
Let’s dive in!
What Is Zone 3 Training?
Zone 3 running or training refers to running, or performing any type of exercise, in zone 3 of the heart rate training zone model.
In the traditional model of heart rate training, there are five intensity zones that correlate to different ranges of your relative maximum heart rate.
Zone 1 is the lowest-intensity heart rate zone, and zone 5 is the highest-intensity heart rate zone.
Here is a quick rundown of the five heart rate zones:
|Zone||Percentage of Maximum Heart Rate||Feels Like||Training Goals and Uses|
|Zone 1||50-60%||Very easy recovery, barely jogging||Complete recovery, getting the body moving without stressing it|
|Zone 2||60-70%||Easy recovery jogging, conversational pace||Recovery runs, long runs, aerobic cross training, building endurance|
|Zone 3||70-80%||Challenging, but doable, sustainable for longer distance races (10k-marathon)||Tempo runs and race pace work for longer races|
|Zone 4||80-90%||Uncomfortable; around 84% of your max heart rate, you hit your ventilatory threshold, so your body starts relying on anaerobic metabolism to produce energy||Interval training, shorter races, boosting performance, the upper end of tempo runs|
|Zone 5||90-100%||An all-out effort, usually only sustainable for 30-60 seconds||Increasing speed, strides, finishing kick, short intervals, hill repeats, plyometrics|
To determine your heart rate zones, you multiply your maximum heart rate by the corresponding percentage of each heart rate zone.
You can estimate your max heart rate with the Fox Formula: 220-age in years. However, according to researchers, a more accurate estimation for max heart rate can be found through the following formulas:
- Maximum Heart Rate for Males = 208.609-0.716 x age
- Maximum Heart Rate for Females = 209.273-0.804 x age
What Are the Benefits of Zone 3 Training?
Zone 3 training is intended to develop your ability to run simultaneously farther and faster. It is not meant to be a training zone for everyday distance runs or recovery workouts but rather specific targeted workouts like tempo runs and threshold intervals.
Tempo runs and threshold workouts span Zones 3 and 4, and these workouts have important training benefits.These workouts condition the body to “get comfortable being uncomfortable“ and can increase your lactate threshold, or the intensity level at which your body shifts from being able to produce nearly all of the necessary ATP (cellular energy) from aerobic metabolism (with oxygen) to anaerobic metabolism.
The metabolic changeover that occurs at this physiological point is associated with a rapid increase in fatigue and a sensation of heavy, tired, burning legs.
Therefore, from a physiological standpoint, tempo runs, and threshold intervals improve your ability to produce energy aerobically at higher intensities and to clear acidic metabolic waste products as quickly as they are being produced so that you do not experience an appreciable decrease in pH, an acidic environment that causes a significant decrease in performance.
Although the lactate threshold can occur a bit higher (in Zone 4) for fit, conditioned runners, it often occurs in Zone 3 for beginners and less trained runners.
According to research, typical lactate threshold values are as follows:
- Untrained or beginner runners: Corresponds to 60% of your VO2 max.
- Intermediate runners: Corresponds to 65% to 80% of VO2 max.
- Elite and highly competitive runners: 85% to 95% of VO2 max.
Therefore, because Zone 3 corresponds to a heart rate range of 70-80% of your maximum heart rate (which roughly correlates to the same percentage of your VO2 max), Zone 3 running for beginners and intermediate runners is right around the lactate threshold.
There are also mental benefits of Zone 3 training and goal race pace runs in heart rate zone 3. Because the intensity level is somewhat uncomfortable, you are always flirting with the desire to ease up and slow down a bit.
However, because many distance races, such as the half marathon and sometimes the 10k, are run predominantly in Zone 3, spending time with zone three running workouts can help “harden“ your mental toughness to handle being uncomfortable for extended periods of time.
Why Is Zone 3 Training Considered the Grey Zone of Running?
Where Zone 3 training becomes controversial is that many runners spend too much time in this training zone, particularly when they should be doing easier recovery runs in Zone 2.
This can either occur because the runner is not running with a heart rate monitor, so he or she isn’t aware that they are actually running faster and harder than they should be for an “easy“ run, or more often, many runners simply run their “easy runs“ and recovery runs too fast because they believe that running slowly will make them a slower runner and that pushing the pace will improve their performance.
For the first group of runners, wearing a heart rate monitor while running can be a very effective tool to help you be more informed and in control of your training.
For runners who do wear a fitness watch or heart rate monitor or generally just have the mindset that if they can run faster, they should run faster and that running faster will make them a faster runner, it could be helpful to understand why this is not true.
Should You Train In Zone 3?
Not all Zone 3 training is considered running in the grey zone or “grey zone running.”
When you are deliberately running in Zone 3 by doing a tempo run or specific threshold or goal pace workout, any mileage that you do in Zone 3 is indeed highly valuable, effective training.
Where Zone 3 running becomes grey zone training, is when you are supposed to be doing a recovery run or easy run, and you are pushing the intensity too high.
Easy runs should be run in Zone 2, not Zone 3.
When easy runs are run in heart rate Zone 3, your body is having to work too hard, and you are not actually facilitating any type of recovery. In contrast, you are further stressing the body and digging yourself into a deeper hole in terms of how much recovery will be needed to get yourself back to 100% for your next hard workout.
The purpose of easy runs and recovery runs is to improve your aerobic fitness without overtaxing your cardiovascular, metabolic, and muscular systems.
Your body can make all of the necessary physiological adaptations for increased cardiovascular efficiency and improved aerobic endurance by running at a lower heart rate (those in heart rate Zone 2 rather than Zone 3).
Therefore, it is unnecessary to push the pace and bring your heart rate up in Zone 3 during these training runs, and more importantly, it is actually deleterious to your overall performance.
By running harder than you need to, your body isn’t getting the relative rest and recovery it needs, but rather continuing to be stressed and depleted.
Over time, this can lead to overtraining syndrome because your body is never able to fully recover, and you keep stacking more training stress on the body. It is like trying to climb up an avalanche as it pommels down the mountain.
Additionally, on a more immediate time scale, Zone 3 training or running in the grey zone for your easy runs can compromise your performance in your key workouts during the week.
Imagine a scenario where you do a speed workout on the track on Tuesday. If you are supposed to do a recovery run in Zone 2 on Wednesday before doing a tempo run on Thursday, but you do your recovery run in zone 3, your body will not fully recover by the time the tempo run rolls around on Thursday.
Then, when you try to run your tempo run, you will already be starting without a “full tank.“ This can reduce your ability to perform well in the workout and hit the proper paces at the appropriate corresponding heart rates.
Therefore, to avoid grey zone running or accumulate “junk miles,” let go of your ego, run your easy runs actually easy, and use Zone 3 for what it is intended to facilitate.
To delve into more detail about Tempo and Threshold runs, check out our guides: