Obstacles course races, such as a Spartan Race, Warrior Dash, or Tough Mudder, are a fun way to challenge yourself not just as a runner but also test your overall strength, fitness, and mental and physical grit.
Obstacle course races combine running with all sorts of creative and challenging obstacles, such as scaling walls, crawling under netting, running through a field of tires, and swinging on a rope across a body of water.
Many of these obstacle course races are grueling in terms of the total distance, and you may even be subjected to exercise penalties if you are unable to complete an obstacle.
Tough Mudder and Spartan Races are two of the most popular types of obstacle course races. Each “brand” of obstacle course races includes races of different lengths with different sorts of obstacles.
Between a Tough Mudder vs Spartan Race, which is harder? What are the main differences between Tough Mudder and Spartan Races?
In this article, we will discuss what Spartan Races and Tough Mudders entail and the differences between Tough Mudder vs Spartan Races.
We will look at:
- What is a Spartan Race?
- What Is a Tough Mudder?
- Tough Mudder Vs Spartan Race: Which is Harder?
Let’s jump in!
What is a Spartan Race?
Before we look at which obstacle course race is harder, let’s look at each individually.
The Spartan Race began in 2010 by creator Joe De Sena.Although there were only about 500 finishers in the first year of Spartan racing, there are now millions of people who finish a Spartan Race every year around the world.
There is even an annual Spartan Race World Championships to crown the champion Spartan Racer.
To help make the Spartan Race more accessible for athletes of different fitness levels and ages, there are different levels of Spartan Races.
This allows athletes to “grow“ within the Spartan Race family of events, beginning with entry-level Spartan Races and working their way up to the most challenging and demanding Spartan Races.
Although there is some variability, here are some of the most common levels of Spartan Races:
- Spartan Sprint: This is the entry-level Spartan Race that is best for beginners. The Spartan sprint events are typically 3 to 5 miles long and have about 20 obstacles per race.
- Spartan Super: One step up from the entry-level Spartan Sprint is the Spartan Super. These races are usually between 7.7 and 11 miles long. You will typically encounter about 24 obstacles.
- Spartan Beast: Most people who truly want to test themselves and tackle a grueling Spartan Race set their sights on the Spartan Beast. This event usually involves running between 12 and 16 miles and tackling 28 obstacles.
- Spartan Ultra Beast: For gutsy competitors who are up for a true challenge, the Spartan Ultra Beast is usually about 28 miles long and may have upwards of 70 obstacles.
What Is a Tough Mudder?
A Tough Mudder is another popular obstacle course race with races held worldwide. The name speaks to the fact that most of these Tough Mudder obstacle courses involve some amount of mud and water during the obstacles and the running course itself.
Like Spartan Races, there are different Tough Mudder events.
The Tough Mudder Challenges are entry-level events open to anyone, including kids, while the Tough Mudder Races are the more competitive obstacle race course events.
Within the Tough Mudder races, there are different levels:
- Half Mudder: This is the entry-level Tough Mudder race. Athletes have to run about 5 miles and tackle various obstacles along the course.
- Tough Mudder Classic: The distance of this race bumps up to 8 to 10 miles with additional obstacles.
- Tough Mudder Night Version: As the name suggests, this type of Tough Mudder race takes place at night, so you have to navigate the obstacles in poor lighting, and the resistance is slightly longer, usually around 10 to 12 miles.
- 24-Hour Tough Mudder: This is a true endurance event rather than a distance event. Racers compete for 24 hours.
Tough Mudder Vs Spartan Race: Which is Harder?
In the obstacle course race circuit, most people consider the Spartan Race to be more challenging than a Tough Mudder.
The Spartan Race requires more individual physical strength and endurance. Although there are some Spartan Sprint races and short Spartan Races, when you are trying to compare Spartan Races vs Tough Mudders overall, the average Spartan Race is more difficult than a Tough Mudder.
Here are some of the main differences between a Spartan Race vs Tough Mudder:
#1: Penalties for Failing Obstacles
One of the biggest differences between a Spartan Race vs Tough Mudder is in the penalty system in a Spartan Race.
When you are competing in a Spartan Race, certain obstacles are required. This means that you cannot continue the race if you are unable to complete the obstacle.
Other obstacles are subject to a penalty of 30 burpees. This means that if you fail to complete the obstacle properly, you can continue in the race, but you must complete 30 burpees before doing so.
This may not sound like a lot, but when was the last time you did 30 burpees and then continued running? Imagine needing to do this numerous times over the duration of the Spartan Race. Most of these races have a minimum of 20 to 30 obstacles.
With the Tough Mudder obstacle course races, you can skip an obstacle if you need to.
This is the primary reason why most people agree that Spartan Races are more challenging than Tough Mudder events.
#2: Race Atmosphere/Competitiveness
Another difference between a Tough Mudder vs Spartan race is in the atmosphere itself.
Both obstacle course races try to combine a sense of fun along with a competitive spirit, but the race atmosphere at a Tough Mudder tends to be a little more relaxed and fun than a Spartan Race, which is typically taken more seriously.
Even the nature of the obstacles in a Tough Mudder vs Spartan Race speaks to this difference.
A lot of the Tough Mudder obstacles are meant to be a bit playful and fun while still physically challenging to some degree, whereas the Spartan Race obstacles fall much more squarely in the physically-challenging camp.
#3: Individual vs Group Effort
Another primary difference between Tough Mudder vs Spartan Races is that Tough Mudder races tend to be more of a group effort or partner effort when it comes to the obstacles.
Not only do many pre-assembled teams compete in Tough Mudders and try to stick together and work together throughout the entire race, but even for individuals who are competing in a Tough Mudder race, many of the obstacles involve working with the other fellow racers who arrive at the obstacle at the same time.
There is more of a team effort to conquer these obstacles.
The Spartan Race is really an individual race. You tackle all of the obstacles on your own except on rare occasions.
In this way, a Spartan Race tests your own physical strength and capabilities more directly, while a Tough Mudder emphasizes social support and community building. One approach isn’t necessarily better than the other, but there is a rather distinct difference.
Although this is a bit more subjective and not necessarily universal across the board, most Spartan Races provide better swag and prizes than Tough Mudder races.
This, of course, has nothing to do with which race is harder, but it’s a difference between Tough Mudder vs Spartan races that’s interesting to note.
Although some of the obstacles that you will encounter in a Spartan Race or a Tough Mudder race are actually quite similar or the same, the fact that you have to do the obstacle by yourself in a Spartan Race by default makes the Spartan obstacles harder than the Tough Mudder obstacles.
For example, most Tough Mudder and Spartan Races have a log carry obstacle.
This is much easier to conquer in a Tough Mudder when you can assemble a group to carry the log together.
Moreover, the distance that you have to carry the log is usually a bit longer in the Spartan Races vs Tough Mudder races.
What do you think? Have you done a Spartan Race, Tough Mudder, or Warrior Dash?
Let us know which obstacle course race you think is the hardest!
If you are thinking about training for a Spartan race, we have the guide just for you: How To Train For A Spartan Race: Training Guide + 3 Surefire Workouts.